How to Compare Cash Offers Using Seller Net Proceeds

Posted in:

A cash offer is a purchase price, not a promise that the same amount will arrive in your bank account. To compare offers for a Jacksonville house, separate the price from the costs deducted at closing and the work you would pay for before closing.

Start with one worksheet for each offer

Use the same categories for every buyer: purchase price, seller-paid closing charges, buyer credits, mortgage payoff, other required payoffs, and estimated cash to you. Then record expenses outside closing, such as a repair you agree to finish, storage, or an extra month of carrying costs. Keeping those costs separate prevents counting an expense twice.

The CFPB explains that a mortgage payoff can differ from your statement balance because it is calculated for a particular payoff date and can include additional amounts. Ask your closing provider to obtain the appropriate figure rather than subtracting an old balance from an offer.

A worked comparison

This is a hypothetical teaching example, not an Obi offer or a forecast of local prices. Assume the same $120,000 mortgage payoff applies to both proposals and there are no other payoffs.

Item Offer A Offer B
Purchase price $220,000 $214,000
Seller closing charges $6,000 $1,000
Buyer credit $4,000 $0
Mortgage payoff $120,000 $120,000
Estimated proceeds $90,000 $93,000

Offer B has the lower price but produces $3,000 more under these assumptions. Actual charges and their allocation depend on the transaction. Replace every number with an itemized estimate before using this method to make a decision.

Compare the conditions beside the numbers

Write down whether the buyer still needs an inspection, financing, another purchaser, or a title issue resolved. Record the inspection deadline and proposed closing date. A higher estimate with unresolved conditions is a different proposition from an offer whose remaining steps are clearly documented.

Ask what happens if a later walkthrough reveals a repair issue. Does the agreement allow renegotiation or cancellation, and when? A verbal promise that the price will never change is not a substitute for understanding the agreement.

Use ranges where information is incomplete

If cleanup or moving costs are uncertain, record a realistic low and high estimate rather than pretending you have a precise result. Mark unconfirmed charges as unknown. Ask which expenses the buyer covers and have the closing provider show the allocation. “No commission” answers one question; it does not answer every question about proceeds.

Use this worksheet when reviewing a Jacksonville cash home offer. Read about the selling process and bring the same questions when you request a proposal from Obi Buys.

Source and scope

CFPB: Mortgage payoff amounts supports the reference points discussed above. The checklists and examples are editorial planning aids, not individualized legal, tax or financial advice. Consult the appropriate professional for your transaction.